Grant Thornton Australia

Grant Thornton uses cookies to monitor the performance of this website and improve user experience. If you are happy to accept cookies from this site, please check the box. To find out more about cookies, what they are and how we use them, please see our privacy notice, which also provides information on how to delete cookies from your hard drive.

How to be COVIDSafe when visiting Grant Thornton offices. Find out how

Global site
  • Global site
  • Africa
  • Americas
  • Asia Pacific
  • Europe
  • Middle East
Grant Thorton Logo
Grant Thornton Logo Grant Thornton Logo
  • Skip to content
  • Skip to navigation
Contact us
Close Global search
  • Insights
  • Services
  • Industries
  • Meet our people
  • Careers
  • News centre
  • Locations
  • About us
  • Audit
  • Tax
  • Risk
  • Forensics
  • Deals
  • Finance and funding
  • Insolvency
  • Restructuring and turnaround
  • Business services
  • Consulting

  • Market services
  • Asia
  • Indigenous advisory
Audit Home
  • Compliance audits & reviews
  • Audit quality
  • Financial reporting advisory
  • Audit advisory
Insight CPS 234 Tripartite Review – Considerations for APRA-regulated entities
Following the announcement of the CPS tripartite audits in November 2021, APRA began issuing notices to regulated entities to undergo the independent assessment. The reviews are part of APRA’s four year strategy to increase the rigor of compliance with CPS 234: Information Security.
Tax Home
  • Corporate tax & advisory
  • Private business tax & advisory
  • Tax compliance
  • Employment tax
  • International tax
  • GST, stamp duty & indirect tax
  • Tax law
  • Research and development & government incentives
  • Transfer pricing
  • Data transformation and analytics
  • Corporate simplification
Client alert Final round of funding for medtech commercialisation
The second and final round of the Clinical Translation and Commercialisation Medtech (CTCM) program opens on 9 September 2022.
Risk Home
  • Payroll assurance
  • Cyber resilience
  • Internal audit
  • Financial crime
  • Consumer Data Right
  • Risk management
  • Controls assurance
  • Governance
  • Regulatory compliance
Insight CPS 234 Tripartite Review – Considerations for APRA-regulated entities
Following the announcement of the CPS tripartite audits in November 2021, APRA began issuing notices to regulated entities to undergo the independent assessment. The reviews are part of APRA’s four year strategy to increase the rigor of compliance with CPS 234: Information Security.
Forensics Home
  • Forensic accounting and dispute advisory
  • Investigations
  • Digital forensics
  • eDiscovery
Client alert Fair Work Ombudsman releases its strategic priorities and key industry focus for FY23
The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) has announced its strategic priorities for 2022-23 including where audit and enforcement activities will be undertaken in relation to wage underpayments.
Deals Home
  • Mergers and acquisitions
  • Acquisition search & strategy
  • Divestments
  • Operational deal services
  • Transaction advisory
  • Business valuations
  • Tax in mergers & acquisition
Insight Tax in M&A: Questions to ask your business and deal team
While Australia has shown strong acquirer appetite and businesses from all industries are finding great success and outstanding returns with their acquisition and divestment strategies, M&A activity now faces an uncertain future.
Finance and funding Home
  • Corporate finance
  • Debt advisory
  • Working capital optimisation
  • Capital markets
  • Capital raising
  • Private equity
  • Financial modelling
  • Payments advisory
Insight Tax in M&A: Questions to ask your business and deal team
While Australia has shown strong acquirer appetite and businesses from all industries are finding great success and outstanding returns with their acquisition and divestment strategies, M&A activity now faces an uncertain future.
Insolvency Home
  • Voluntary administration & DOCA
  • Corporate insolvency & liquidation
  • Complex and international insolvency
  • Safe Harbour advisory
  • Bankruptcy and personal insolvency
  • Creditor advisory services
  • Small business restructuring process
Client alert Can your business leverage the Small Business Restructure process to clean up old debt?
As the economy continues to battle ongoing waves of COVID-19, businesses who are struggling to pay legacy debts may be left wondering what their future might look like.
Restructuring and turnaround Home
  • Independent business reviews
  • Commercial performance
  • Safe Harbour advisory
  • Corporate simplification
  • Director advisory services
  • Debt advisory
Client alert ATO puts up to 50,000 taxpayers on alert for looming Director Penalty Notices
On 28 March, the ATO sent its strongest message on debt enforcement since the COVID-19 pandemic commenced, advising that it is now issuing letters to taxpayers informing them about their potential personal liability for company tax debts under the Director Penalty Notice (DPN) programme.
Business services Home
  • Business planning & strategy
  • Private business company secretarial services
  • Outsourced accounting services
  • Superannuation and SMSF
  • Management reporting
  • Financial reporting
  • Forecasting & budgeting
  • ATO audit support
  • Family business consulting
  • Private business taxation and structuring
  • Outsourced CFO services
Consulting Home
  • Management consulting
  • Financial consulting
Insight Earning trust and building credibility and influence as a CFO
Whether you’ve just secured the coveted role of Chief Financial Officer (CFO) or you’re on the cusp of becoming one, one thing’s for sure: you’re embarking on a high-stakes, high pressure role.
Asia Home
  • China
  • India
  • Japan
  • Case study: Restructuring solutions
  • Agribusiness, Food & Beverage
  • Energy & Resources
  • Financial Services
  • Health & Aged Care
  • Life Sciences
  • Manufacturing
  • Not for Profit
  • Professional Services
  • Real Estate & Construction
  • Retail & Consumer Products
  • Technology, Media & Telecommunications
Agribusiness, Food & Beverage Home
Client alert Fair Work Ombudsman releases its strategic priorities and key industry focus for FY23
The Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) has announced its strategic priorities for 2022-23 including where audit and enforcement activities will be undertaken in relation to wage underpayments.
Energy & Resources Home
Guidebook A guide to transition from exploration to development and production
A deep dive into the accounting, tax and finance implications as you transition from exploration through development and ultimately, production.
Financial Services Home
Insight CPS 234 Tripartite Review – Considerations for APRA-regulated entities
Following the announcement of the CPS tripartite audits in November 2021, APRA began issuing notices to regulated entities to undergo the independent assessment. The reviews are part of APRA’s four year strategy to increase the rigor of compliance with CPS 234: Information Security.
Health & Aged Care Home
Client alert Final round of funding for medtech commercialisation
The second and final round of the Clinical Translation and Commercialisation Medtech (CTCM) program opens on 9 September 2022.
Manufacturing Home
Insight Investment into innovation encouraging stability in manufacturing
Australian manufacturers have been through difficult times, particularly with the shutdown of the automotive industry, but remaining businesses are proving to be agile and resilient having already battled through lots of challenges. In addition, the accelerating pace of new technologies being introduced, combined with COVID-19 disruption and the Government’s substantial industry support, many manufacturing business models have been fundamentally challenged for the better.
Not for Profit Home
Insight How not-for-profit organisations can shift from ‘survival mode’ into sustainability
We saw COVID threaten the sustainability for many not-for-profit (NFP) organisations, forcing some to make operational changes or to shut their doors, and others to adapt and drive innovation to achieve their mission. But what does it mean to be a sustainable NFP, and how do these organisations then remain sustainable for years to come?
Professional Services Home
Client alert ATO targets “Everett Assignments” by professionals
Following on from the ATO’s guide to professional services firms’ allocation of profits in PCG 2021/4, the ATO has now further tightened its compliance scrutiny of individual professionals’ ability to assign or stream income away from themselves to family members by releasing its compliance approach to so-called Everett assignments.
Real Estate & Construction Home
Insight Infrastructure in Western Australia – a strong and renewed focus on investment
The Western Australian Government has recently handed down its 2022-23 State budget announcing a record $33.9 billion investment in infrastructure over the next four years. The significant investment in infrastructure will not only create a strong pipeline of future economic activity but will shape the way we live and move around the state.
Retail & Consumer Products Home
We are Retail We are Retail
Our senior people have worked in retail for 25 years. That’s 25 years of experience helping some of Australia’s largest and most important businesses to be more successful. Put simply, we implement solutions that grow businesses, and our work makes a positive and profound impact on the lives of millions of people around Australia.
Technology, Media & Telecommunications Home
Client alert Digital Games Tax Offset
Income Tax Assessment Amendment (Digital Games Tax Offset) Bill 2021: Measure for Consultation
  • Careers Home
  • Working at Grant Thornton
  • Student opportunities
  • Experienced careers
  • Contact us
  • Alumni
Working at Grant Thornton Home
  • Flexibility
  • Your career and development
  • Diversity and inclusion
  • In the community
  • What we offer you
Student opportunities Home
  • Graduates
  • Vacationer Program
  • The application process
  • FAQs
  • Student application tips and tricks
  • Positions available
Experienced careers Home
  • Client spotlight
  • Positions available
    • EN
    • Contact us
    1. Home
    2. Client alerts
    3. 2021
    4. The continuing evolution of stamp duty

    When “land” does not mean land and “fixed” does not mean fixed – the continuing evolution of stamp duty

    23 Mar 2021

    The continuing evolution of stamp duty

    Yesterday, RevenueWA issued Revenue Ruling DA26.0 (“Ruling”) which sets out its interpretation of major amendments which commenced on 13 June 2019, some 21 months ago. While the guidance is welcome, it is not necessarily good news for taxpayers.

    While the amendments were comprehensive, and changed a number of provisions in the Duties Act 2008 (WA), the Ruling focuses on the meaning of things “fixed to land” and fixed infrastructure rights.  While the concept of “fixed to land” (as distinct from a “fixture”) is now commonplace in Australian stamp duty law, fixed infrastructure rights are unique to Western Australia.  The changes were promoted as making it easier to determine whether a transaction is subject to duty and to prevent synthetic arrangements which technically circumvented the Western Australian duty net, with the result that the duty net has been significantly widened, and now catches more transaction than it otherwise would have.

    Both the concepts of fixed to land and fixed infrastructure rights broaden the meaning of “land” or “land asset” to things which are not taken to be land for any other legal (or accounting) purpose.

    Things fixed to land

    The concept of things “fixed to land” or things “fixed to the land” has now been introduced in duties legislation across Australia except the Australian Capital Territory. While it has expanded the duty base, the policy justification has been to take away the technical legal difference between fixtures and chattels (or goods), with a “fixture” requiring an objective intention for the thing to be permanently fixed to the land for the better use and enjoyment of the land.  The expanded concept of “fixed to land” has sought to remove the objective intention test.  Practically, this has meant that when asking clients to identify things which are “fixed” for duty purposes, the usual message is whether the thing is somehow physically fixed to land by more than its own weight (eg bolted to a floor, wall or ceiling, even for stability purposes).

    The Ruling goes further than that. 

    The Ruling makes it clear that RevenueWA will treat something that is not physically “fixed to land” by more than its own weight (ie merely resting on the ground) as “fixed to land” in circumstances where “it is rendered immovable”.  While such a thing might be a “fixture” (and therefore already taken to be land under normal principles), ordinary logic is not likely to conclude it is “fixed”.  The example used is railway infrastructure as fixed even though its component parts merely rest on the ground, with counterexamples that portable toilets, industrial bins, shipping containers and photocopiers are not fixed.  In our experience, there are many examples of things which fall between a railway line and a shipping container, particularly in the context of a manufacturing facility, which makes it difficult to determine where the line is.

    It seems to us that if a crane or gantry can merely pick something up from the factory floor and move it, it should not be “fixed”.  However, if it needs to be destroyed in order to move it, it is “fixed” even though it might just be resting on the ground.  That is not to say that is the bright line test for all assets, and there are undoubtedly many examples in between these broad concepts, with the result that many assets need to be considered on a case by case basis. 

    You might think that such nuanced concepts are pretty subtle (and perhaps absurd) just to determine the extent to which duty is payable on a transaction, but unfortunately these are everyday conversations when advising on these transactions, and without proper advice, it is easy to come to the (incorrect) conclusion that a transaction is not exposed to duty.

    Fixed infrastructure rights – taxing infrastructure transactions

    The concept of fixed infrastructure rights is unique to Western Australia, and designed to prevent synthetic “land” transactions from escaping duty.  Nevertheless, the Ruling identifies that ordinary commercial transactions, which are not structured to avoid duty, can also be caught.

    The clearest examples are that the operator of a power generation facility or railway, which are taken to hold a “land asset” even though they are merely an operator of the infrastructure and do not actually hold any interest in land.  Another example is a Private Public Partnership (or PPP), particularly one that involves social infrastructure (eg, prison, sporting stadium, railway or schools).  Typically these transactions are quite properly structured as giving the consortium a long term right by way of licence to operate the asset which it has just built in partial consideration for the risk and expense of construction.  It is seen as the conventional and economically efficient way to deliver major infrastructure in Australia, particularly for government and quasi-government bodies, and is not typically designed with a purpose of duty avoidance. 

    It would seem that while RevenueWA will not seek to tax the entry into PPP arrangements, it does intend to tax the later selldown of the project in its operation phase.  Such cost should now be built into the economic model, even at the start, as a later buyer will need to factor duty at up to 5.15% on its acquisition.  While this would already be the outcome for a PPP which is based on a lease (such as a toll road) in other States and Territories, it is a distinct difference in tax treatment for social infrastructure PPPs, with the tax ultimately needing to be built into the cost of acquiring an interest in new or existing Western Australian infrastructure.

    For more information, please contact:

    Steven Paterson
    Steven Paterson
    Partner Sydney
    Email address https://www.linkedin.com/in/stevenpaterson/ Steven Paterson VCard
    View full profile

    Subscribe to receive our publications

    Subscribe now to be kept up-to-date with timely and relevant insights, unique to the nature of your business, your areas of interest and the industry in which you operate.

    Subscribe

    Share this page

    • Share this page on Facebook LinkedIn
    • Share this page on Twitter Twitter
    • Share this page on LinkedIn LinkedIn
    • Share this page on Wechat WeChat
    • Share this page via email Email
    • Grant Thornton on Youtube
    • LinkedIn icon
    • Twitter icon
    • Facebook icon
    Connect
    • Contact us
    • Locations
    • Meet our people
    • Subscribe
    • Staff portal
    About
    • Careers
    • News centre
    • Client alerts
    • Grant Thornton Foundation
    • Grant Thornton Affinity
    Legal
    • Privacy
    • Compliance and ethics
    • Modern slavery statement
    • Disclaimer
    • Site map

    © 2022 Grant Thornton Australia Limited – All rights reserved