Insight

Funds tracing in family provision claims

By: Thomas Caldow

Quick summary
  • A family provision claim may require looking beyond the estate inventory to understand the deceased’s broader financial relationships. Funds tracing can identify and quantify financial support, claimant contributions, lifetime benefits, gifts or loans and transactions involving other beneficiaries or related entities.
  • A balanced tracing exercise examines money moving in both directions between the deceased and a claimant, using bank statements, accounting records and supporting documents to test competing accounts and reconstruct the financial relationship. This can be particularly valuable where informal arrangements developed over many years or parties disagree about the nature and purpose of payments.
  • Forensic accounting can provide an objective financial chronology and transaction schedule to improve disclosure, identify gaps, narrow disputed issues and provide a more reliable factual foundation for negotiation, mediation or litigation. It does not determine whether a family provision claim should succeed, but can help establish what the contemporaneous financial records actually show.
A family provision claim often begins with an estate inventory setting out the assets and liabilities identified at the date of death. That inventory is important, but it may not tell the full financial story.
Contents

The deceased may have supported a claimant over many years. The claimant may also have contributed money towards the deceased's property, business or living expenses. Significant payments may have been made to other beneficiaries, or assets may have moved through companies, trusts or self-managed superannuation funds (SMSFs).

Where the parties disagree about these matters, funds tracing can help establish what the contemporaneous financial records show. It does not decide the legal outcome of the claim, but can provide a clearer factual foundation for disclosure, negotiation and mediation.

Looking beyond the estate inventory

An estate inventory is a snapshot of a particular point in time. A family provision claim may require a broader understanding of the deceased's financial relationships, including:

  • regular payments made to or for a claimant
  • money advanced to purchase a home or establish a business
  • financial contributions made by the claimant to the deceased
  • improvements funded by a claimant to property owned by the deceased
  • transfers described as gifts by one party and loans by another
  • significant payments to other beneficiaries, or 
  • transactions involving companies, trusts, an SMSF or an enduring power of attorney.

These matters may be addressed in affidavits or witness statements. However, recollections can differ, particularly where arrangements were informal and developed over many years. Bank statements, accounting records and supporting documents provide an objective starting point for testing those recollections.

What can funds tracing establish?

Funds tracing involves analysing financial records to identify the source, movement and application of money. Depending on the issues in dispute, it may establish:

  • the amount, frequency and duration of financial support
  • payments made directly to third parties for a claimant's benefit
  • funds contributed by a claimant towards the deceased's expenses or assets
  • the source of money used to acquire or improve property
  • transfers involving related entities or other beneficiaries, or 
  • material changes in the deceased's financial position. 

The work may require transactions to be matched across several accounts and reconciled to loan agreements, invoices, settlement statements, accounting records, emails and other documents.

The objective is not simply to produce a list of transactions. It is to reconstruct the relevant financial relationship in a form that assists the parties and their legal advisers.

Following money in both directions

A balanced tracing exercise should consider money moving in both directions. A claimant may have paid the deceased's living or medical expenses, funded renovations, contributed towards an asset or advanced money to a family business.

At the same time, the deceased may have transferred money to the claimant, paid expenses on their behalf, discharged a debt, contributed towards their home or business, or provided accommodation.

Reviewing only one side of the relationship can create an incomplete picture. The analysis should be neutral, consistently applied and directed to the financial issues genuinely in dispute.

Examples

The following hypothetical examples illustrate how funds tracing may assist in different circumstances.

After Margaret died, her son Daniel made a family provision claim. Daniel had lived nearby and said that over 12 years, he regularly paid Margaret's council rates, home insurance, medical expenses and the cost of repairs to her property. Daniel said these contributions reduced his capacity to save and provide for his family. While funds tracing would not determine the wider effect of those contributions on Daniel, it could quantify the payments and establish when they were made.

The executor, Daniel's sister Claire, accepted that he had assisted their mother. However, she said Margaret had also provided Daniel with substantial financial support, including $180,000 towards the deposit on his home and several payments directly to his mortgage. Daniel said the home deposit repaid earlier amounts he had advanced to Margaret. Claire said it was a lifetime gift that should form part of the broader financial history considered by the parties. 

Undertaking a funds-tracing exercise could examine Margaret's and Daniel's bank records to identify payments in both directions. It can quantify Daniel's payments for rates, insurance, medical costs and renovations, trace the source and timing of the home-deposit funds, identify mortgage payments made by Margaret, and compare the transactions with emails, invoices, loan records and accounting descriptions. 

The analysis can establish what was paid, when it was paid and whether the parties' assertions are consistent with the contemporaneous records. 

Robert and Maya lived together for 14 years in a de facto relationship. The home was registered in Robert's name and was purchased before the relationship. During their time together, Maya's salary was paid into a joint account used for mortgage repayments, household expenses and renovations. Robert continued to operate a separate personal account, but regularly transferred money between that account, the joint account and his private company's bank account. 

After Robert died, Maya made a family provision claim, and a claim for an equitable interest in the property. She said the couple had pooled their finances and that she had contributed substantially to the home, the mortgage, renovations and their shared standard of living. The executor, Robert’s eldest son Michael, said the benefits that Maya had received from the relationship exceeded any contribution. In particular, Michael pointed to a holiday house purchased in their joint names, funded exclusively by Robert. 

A fund tracing exercise could reconstruct the financial relationship over a defined period. It can identify Maya's salary deposits, mortgage and renovation payments from the joint account, transfers from Robert or his company, major household expenses, amounts applied for each person's benefit and the source of funds used for significant improvements to the property and other assets. 

This can also assist the parties to distinguish ordinary shared living expenses from identifiable contributions towards an asset or liability. It can also reveal whether funds described as Robert's, Maya's or company money had been mixed before being applied. 

When should tracing be considered?

A properly scoped tracing exercise can establish a chronology, quantify payments over time, identify indirect payments, test assertions against contemporaneous records and reveal gaps in disclosure. A single, agreed schedule of relevant transactions (or common financial dataset) can also help narrow the issues before mediation.

Funds tracing may be useful where:

  • the parties give materially different accounts of financial support
  • substantial lifetime benefits are alleged
  • a claimant says they contributed to an estate asset
  • payments passed through several accounts or related entities
  • the estate inventory appears inconsistent with the deceased's known position
  • undocumented loans or advances are disputed, or 
  • the matter is approaching mediation without agreement on the financial history. 

Not every matter requires a full reconstruction of the deceased’s financial affairs. An initial review can focus on the largest disputed transactions, the most relevant accounts and the period in which the alleged support or contributions occurred. The findings can then inform whether further tracing is proportionate to the value and complexity of the dispute.

This staged approach helps assess whether a broader reconstruction is proportionate to the amount and issues in dispute. It can also identify missing records early, before positions become entrenched or a mediation is delayed.

How can forensic accounting assist?

Forensic accountants can independently analyse bank transactions, reconstruct the deceased's financial position, quantify payments to claimants and beneficiaries, examine contributions towards assets and expenses, reconcile related-party loan accounts and trace the source of property-purchase funds.

Forensic accounting provides a factual transaction schedule, a chronology for mediation or, where opinion evidence is required, an independent expert report. However, the role and scope should be clear from the outset. An expert should distinguish between what the records establish, what may reasonably be inferred and what remains uncertain.

Funds tracing will not determine whether a family provision claim should succeed or the amount of any further provision. It can, however, improve disclosure, narrow the matters in dispute and provide a more reliable foundation for negotiation, mediation or litigation.

For more information about funds tracing and forensic accounting in family provision and contested estate matters, contact Thomas Caldow or a member of the Grant Thornton Australia Forensic Consulting team.

Learn more about how our Forensics services can help you
Visit our Forensics page