Insight

When the deceased commingled funds

By: Thomas Caldow

Quick summary
  • Funds tracing in deceased estates is not limited to suspected misconduct. Where a deceased person moved money between personal accounts, private companies, family trusts and SMSFs, executors and beneficiaries may need to reconstruct those transactions to understand whose money it was, why it moved and whether related assets or liabilities arise.
  • Commingled finances can make date-of-death balances misleading or incomplete. Transfers between personal and related-entity accounts, informal loans, expenses paid on behalf of other entities and jointly funded asset purchases can affect estate assets and liabilities, share values, related-party balances and ultimately the amount available to beneficiaries.
  • Forensic accounting can help trace funds across personal, company, trust and SMSF accounts, reconcile bank records with accounting treatments, reconstruct inter-entity loans and asset funding, and distinguish established facts from assumptions. This can give executors, beneficiaries and legal advisers a clearer factual foundation for estate administration, further enquiries and potential disputes.
Funds tracing in a deceased estate is often associated with concerns about transactions undertaken by an enduring power of attorney (EPOA), executor or family member. In those matters, the analysis may investigate whether funds were misappropriated or used for an unauthorised purpose.

However, suspected misconduct is not the only reason an executor or beneficiary may need to understand the movement of money.

In some estates, the uncertainty arises from the way the deceased managed their own financial affairs during their lifetime. Money may have moved between personal bank accounts, private companies, family trusts and self-managed superannuation funds (SMSFs) without a consistent description or clear supporting documentation.

The deceased may have understood the purpose of each transfer, however after their death, executors and beneficiaries must reconstruct those arrangements from the records left behind.

One individual, several financial capacities

A person who controls a private business or family wealth structure may operate in several capacities. The same person might be:

  • the holder of a personal bank account
  • a director and shareholder of a private company
  • a trustee or beneficiary of a family trust
  • a director of the corporate trustee of an SMSF, or
  • a lender to, or borrower from, one or more related entities.

The practical distinction between these roles may have appeared unimportant to the deceased. They may have viewed the accounts as part of one financial structure under their control.

The legal and financial distinction can nevertheless be significant. Company money is not necessarily the director's personal money. An SMSF asset is not necessarily an estate asset. Similarly, money held in the deceased's personal account may be subject to a corresponding liability to a related entity.

How does commingling occur?

Commingling does not necessarily involve deliberate concealment or misappropriation. It may arise through informal practices that develop over many years, including: 

  • company income deposited into a personal account
  • private expenses paid from a company bank account
    company or trust expenses paid personally by the deceased
  • transfers between personal and SMSF accounts
  • asset purchases funded from several accounts
  • loan repayments made without reference to the original advance
  • transfers recorded only as 'loan', 'drawings' or 'transfer', or
  • one entity paying expenses on behalf of another without reimbursement.

Each transaction may have had a legitimate explanation. The difficulty for the executor is identifying and substantiating that explanation.

Why date-of-death balances may not be enough

An estate inventory ordinarily records the assets and liabilities identified at the date of death. Where funds have been commingled, account balances may tell only part of the story.

The bank statements can establish the movement of the money. Without further evidence, they may not establish what the transaction represented. That distinction may affect:

  • the assets included in the estate
  • liabilities owed by the estate
  • the value of shares held by the deceased
  • amounts recoverable by a company or trust, or
  • the amount ultimately available for distribution to beneficiaries.

The same issue can arise in reverse. If the deceased used personal money to fund a company expense or acquire an asset held by an SMSF, the payment does not itself make the underlying asset part of the estate. It may instead indicate a loan, contribution, reimbursement entitlement or another financial relationship requiring further consideration.

When should executors and advisers act?

A well-defined tracing exercise can help executors and advisers quantify transfers, test accounting treatments against bank records, distinguish established facts from assumptions and focus requests for further evidence. It may also narrow a dispute by identifying which transactions are explained and which remain in issue.

Potential commingling should be considered early where:

  • the deceased controlled several private entities
  • personal expenses regularly appear in company records
  • significant related-party loan balances are recorded
  • bank records and the general ledger do not reconcile
  • an asset was funded from more than one source
  • beneficiaries dispute whether an amount belongs to the estate
  • the executor cannot explain material transfers, or 
  • an SMSF appears to have transacted with the deceased or a related entity.

Relevant records may include bank statements, loan agreements, trustee and director resolutions, asset-purchase documents, tax returns, general ledgers, emails and correspondence with the deceased's accountants.

How forensic accounting can assist

Forensic accountants can assist executors, beneficiaries, and legal advisers to reconstruct transactions across personal, corporate, trust, and SMSF accounts. The work may include bank transaction analysis, reconstruction of inter-entity loan accounts, tracing the funding of asset purchases, comparison of alternative transaction treatments and preparation of chronologies or flow-of-funds schedules.

Where a dispute proceeds, an independent expert may also be asked to provide an opinion on accounting or financial issues. The analysis should clearly distinguish between what the records establish, what may reasonably be inferred and what remains uncertain. Questions of legal ownership, fiduciary responsibility and recoverability remain matters for legal advice.

A clearer foundation for estate administration

Funds tracing remains an important tool where misconduct by an attorney, executor or another person is suspected. It also has broader applications.

The deceased may have created financial complexity during their lifetime by moving money informally between personal accounts and the entities they controlled. Those arrangements may have been clear to the deceased, but difficult for anyone else to reconstruct.

The relevant question is not always simply, 'where did the money go?' It may also be: whose money was it, in what capacity was the deceased acting, how was the transaction recorded and does another asset or liability arise as a result?

Funds tracing cannot resolve every legal or evidentiary issue. It can, however, provide executors, beneficiaries and their advisers with a clearer factual foundation from which to administer the estate, evaluate competing positions and determine the next appropriate step.

For more information about funds tracing and forensic accounting in deceased estates, contact Thomas Caldow or a member of the Grant Thornton Australia Forensic Consulting team.

Learn more about how our Forensics services can help you
Visit our Forensics page