• Skip to content
  • Skip to navigation

Grant Thornton Australia

Grant Thornton uses cookies to monitor the performance of this website and improve user experience.

If you are happy to accept cookies from this site, please check the box.

To find out more about cookies, what they are and how we use them, please see our privacy notice, which also provides information on how to delete cookies from your hard drive.

How to be COVIDSafe when visiting Grant Thornton offices. Find out how

Global site
  • Global site
  • Algeria
  • Botswana
  • Cameroon
  • Egypt
  • Ethiopia
  • Gabon
  • Guinea
  • Kenya
  • Libya
  • Malawi
  • Mauritius
  • Morocco
  • Nigeria
  • Namibia
  • Senegal
  • South Africa
  • Togo
  • Tunisia
  • Uganda
  • Zambia
  • Zimbabwe
  • Anguilla
  • Antigua
  • Argentina
  • Aruba, Bonaire, Curacao and St. Maarten
  • Bahamas
  • Barbados
  • Bolivia
  • Brazil
  • British Virgin Islands
  • Canada LLP
  • Canada RCGT
  • Cayman Islands
  • Chile
  • Colombia
  • Costa Rica
  • Dominica
  • Ecuador
  • El Salvador
  • Grenada
  • Guatemala
  • Honduras
  • Mexico
  • Montserrat
  • Nicaragua
  • Panama
  • Paraguay
  • Peru
  • Puerto Rico
  • St Kitts
  • St Lucia
  • St Vincent and the Grenadines
  • Trinidad & Tobago
  • United States
  • Uruguay
  • Venezuela
  • Turks & Caicos
  • Afghanistan
  • Australia
  • Bangladesh
  • Cambodia
  • China
  • Hong Kong
  • India
  • Indonesia
  • Japan
  • Korea
  • Malaysia
  • Mongolia
  • Myanmar
  • New Zealand
  • Pakistan
  • Philippines
  • Singapore
  • Taiwan
  • Thailand
  • Vietnam
  • Albania
  • Armenia
  • Austria
  • Azerbaijan
  • Belarus
  • Belgium
  • Bosnia and Herzegovina
  • Bulgaria
  • Channel Islands
  • Croatia
  • Cyprus
  • Czech Republic
  • Denmark
  • Estonia
  • Finland
  • France
  • Georgia
  • Germany
  • Gibraltar
  • Greece
  • Hungary
  • Iceland
  • Ireland
  • Isle of Man
  • Israel
  • Italy - Bernoni
  • Italy - Ria
  • Kazakhstan
  • Kosovo
  • Kyrgyzstan
  • Latvia
  • Liechtenstein
  • Lithuania
  • Luxembourg
  • Macedonia
  • Malta
  • Moldova
  • Monaco
  • Netherlands
  • Northern Ireland
  • Norway
  • Poland
  • Portugal
  • Romania
  • Russia
  • Serbia
  • Slovak Republic
  • Slovenia
  • Spain
  • Sweden
  • Switzerland
  • Tajikistan
  • Turkey
  • Ukraine
  • UK
  • Uzbekistan
  • Bahrain
  • Egypt
  • Jordan
  • Kuwait
  • Oman
  • Qatar
  • Saudi Arabia
  • United Arab Emirates
  • Yemen
  • Lebanon
Grant Thorton Logo

Grant Thornton Logo Grant Thornton Logo

Contact us
  • Insights
  • Services
  • Industries
  • Meet our people
  • Careers
  • News centre
  • Locations
  • About us
  • Audit
  • Tax
  • Private Advisory
  • Financial Advisory
  • Grant Thornton Consulting
  • Asia
Audit Home
  • Audit methodology
  • Audit technology
  • Financial reporting advisory
Tax Home
  • Corporate tax
  • Employee equity reward schemes
  • Fringe benefits tax
  • Global mobility services
  • GST & indirect tax
  • International tax
  • Payroll assurance
  • Research & development
  • Tax compliance
  • Tax governance & risk management
  • Tax in mergers & acquisitions
  • Tax lawyers
  • Transfer pricing
Private Advisory Home
  • Family Business Consulting
  • Family office services
  • Private wealth
  • Superannuation
Financial Advisory Home
  • Corporate finance
  • Debt advisory
  • Forensic consulting
  • Payments advisory
  • Restructuring advisory
Grant Thornton Consulting Home
  • Business risk
  • Human capital
  • Performance improvement
  • Strategy & growth
  • Technology consulting
  • GNC Group Consulting
Asia Home
  • China practice
  • India practice
  • Japan practice
  • Agribusiness, food & beverage
  • Automotive dealers
  • Education
  • Energy & resources
  • Financial services
  • Health & aged care
  • Life sciences
  • Manufacturing
  • Not for Profit
  • Professional services
  • Public sector
  • Real estate & construction
  • Retail & consumer products
  • Technology & media
Agribusiness, food & beverage Home
Bite Size Dealtracker Food, Beverage & Agribusiness industry insights
Key insights for the Australian Food, Beverage & Agribusiness industry.
Financial services Home
  • Banking
  • Fintech
  • Private Health Insurance
  • Superannuation
  • Asset management
  • BEAR FAQs
  • Open banking
Royal Commission wrap up Top 10 things for Financial Services providers
Eleven months on from the first round of hearings for the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, Commissioner Hayne’s final report has been released.
Health & aged care Home
Aged Care Royal Commission Perspectives on the Future of Ageing
Transitions in ageing are not consistent and systematic as they are described by our ageing systems. Sometimes they are incremental, sometimes accidental, sometimes monumental, and they are always personal. We can create something better.
Life sciences Home
Biotechnology Industry Position survey Australia's biotechnology industry drives economic growth
The 2019 Biotechnology Industry Position survey conducted by Ausbiotech and supported by Grant Thornton has revealed that new technologies across regenerative medicine and medicinal cannabis are disrupting the industry, and Australia's global strength in clinical trials continues to drive contributions to the economic and social fabric of the country.
Manufacturing Home
mid-sized business report Manufacturing is critical to our economy – how can we support the sector?
Although the knock-on effects of the Australian automotive industry exiting our country are yet to be fully understood, the industry is evolving, and manufacturing continues to be a major employer and critical to our overall economy.
Not for Profit Home
NATIONAL OUTCOMES MEASUREMENT PROGRAM A practical framework
Royal Commissions and federal budgets are critical things for Nonprofit human service providers to be thinking about at this point in time.
Real estate & construction Home
mid-sized business report Supporting affordable housing requires planning, certainty – and tax reform
There is a lot of noise around the property sector at the moment – and it’s not all positive. Prices are down – but this shouldn’t be a surprise when some markets (namely Sydney & Melbourne) saw unprecedented hikes in recent years.
Retail & consumer products Home
GNC Group Consulting The Technology Trap: Online innovation in retail
I recently attended the NRF Retail Big Show in New York, an overwhelming smorgasbord of retail technology and new store concepts.
Technology & media Home
  • Telecommunications
Scaling-up for Growth From start-up to scale-up
Navigating the complexities of growth and maintaining previous success is a challenge for all mid-size businesses.
  • Working at Grant Thornton
  • Student opportunities
  • Experienced careers
  • Contact us
Working at Grant Thornton Home
  • Flexibility
  • Your career and development
  • Diversity and inclusion
  • In the community
  • What we offer you
Student opportunities Home
  • Graduates
  • Vacationer Program
  • The application process
  • FAQs
  • Student application tips and tricks
Experienced careers Home
  • Client spotlight
  • Grant Thornton Australia | Audit, Tax and Advisory
  • Client alerts
  • 2017
  • High Court decision highlights the importance of a diligent review of land tax assessments

High Court decision highlights the importance of a diligent review of land tax assessments

20 Apr 2017
  • High Court decision highlights the importance of a diligent review of land tax assessments

Many clients have received or are soon to receive land tax assessments and a recent High Court judgment acts as a good reminder of the importance of checking them.

Any erroneous assessments or valuations must be notified to the revenue office as soon as possible and certainly within the period prescribed for in the relevant State or Territory legislation. Failure to do so, as happened in this case, may result in an inability to recover any excess payments or even any penalty or interest imposed.

In Commissioner of State Revenue v ACN 005 057 349 Pty Ltd [2017] HCA 6, the High Court overturned the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court of Victoria decision in which it was held that the Victorian Commissioner of State Revenue refund duplicate land tax paid by the taxpayer.

The High Court decision was made on the basis that the Commissioner did not have the authority to exercise discretion to issue amended assessments and repay excess land tax amounts outside of the time limits allowed for under section 19 of the Land Tax Act 1958 (Vic) (‘LTA’)[1] and the Court of Appeal did not have authority to rule with respect to the expenditure of public funds. Further, the taxpayer was ordered to repay land tax incorrectly refunded by the Commissioner.

The background facts to the case state that the Commissioner notified the taxpayer in early 2012 that the land tax assessments issued for the 2008 to 2011 land tax years in respect of one property (Property A) actually included a valuation of two adjoining properties (Property A and B) owned by the taxpayer, which resulted in the taxpayer paying land tax in respect of Property A twice. Having identified this error, the Commissioner proceeded with refunding the duplicate land tax that had been paid in respect of the 2008 – 2011 land tax years.

The taxpayer subsequently determined that the same duplication error had been made in the assessments issued by the Commissioner in respect of the 1990 to 2002 land tax years. However, the Commissioner refused to issue amended assessments and refunds in respect of the duplicate land tax paid by the taxpayer in these years.

The taxpayer took the matter to the Supreme Court of Victoria, which dismissed the proceedings. However, the taxpayer then appealed the matter to the Court of Appeal of the Supreme Court, which resulted in the Court of Appeal issuing an order requiring the Commissioner to issue amended assessments and repay the excess amounts of land tax the taxpayer had paid in respect of the 1990 to 2002 land tax years.

The Commissioner appealed the decision of the Court of Appeal, taking the matter to the High Court. The High Court ruled that the Court of Appeal erred in its reading and understanding of the applicable section of the LTA, as it did not appreciate that the scope of the Commissioner’s authority to make a refund was provided by, and at the same time limited by, Section 19. Specifically, section 19 provides that the Commissioner has a discretionary power with regard to refunding excess land tax amounts, but must only do so in response to an objection lodged within the time limit expressed in section 90AA, which provides a three-year time limit from the date that the payment of the land tax was made.

As the taxpayer did not lodge an objection within the time limit allowed for in the LTA, the High Court held that the Commissioner did not have authority to repay the excess land tax amounts. Further, having allowed the Commissioner’s appeal, the High Court voided the order issued by the Court of Appeal (being that the Commissioner issue amended assessments and repay the excess land tax to the taxpayer, which the Commissioner had actioned) and ordered the taxpayer to repay the amounts refunded by the Commissioner (as well as interest on these amounts and the Commissioner’s legal costs).

The key learnings from this High Court judgment are to diligently review your land tax assessment on receipt and notify the relevant revenue office within the prescribed period.

 

[1] Note that this Act has been replaced by the Land Tax Act 2005 which came into operation on 1 January 2006.

Next article: Key learnings from recent GST court decisions

For more information, please contact:

Sian Sinclair
Sian Sinclair
Partner & National Head of Real Estate &... Brisbane
Email address https://au.linkedin.com/pub/sian-sinclair/14/9b0/9b5 Sian Sinclair VCard
View full profile
Share this page
  • Share this page on Facebook LinkedIn
  • Share this page on Twitter Twitter
  • Share this page on LinkedIn LinkedIn
  • Share this page on Wechat WeChat
  • Share this page via email Email
  • Follow us on youtube
  • Follow us on linkedin
  • Follow us on twitter
  • Follow us on facebook
Connectclose
  • Contact us
  • Locations
  • Meet our people
  • Subscribe
  • Staff portal
Aboutclose
  • About us
  • Careers
  • News centre
  • Client alerts
  • Grant Thornton Foundation
  • Grant Thornton Affinity
Legalclose
  • Privacy
  • Compliance and ethics
  • Disclaimer
  • Site map

© 2021 Grant Thornton Australia Limited – All rights reserved

    • EN
    • Contact us