Funds tracing in family provision claims
In family provision claims, an estate inventory may not tell the full financial story.
Beyond the numbers: Explore the trends and ideas shaping Australian business. Listen now.
By: Thomas Caldow, Larissa-Ann Sura, Nathan Cerra
12 Mar 2024 4 min read

In a recent NSWSC judgment, this issue was explored by the Court with Black J confirming a common long-standing belief that EBITDA is preferred where irregular depreciation materially effects the valuation conclusion.
EBIT and EBITDA are two of the most common metrics applied by business valuers as a proxy for the future maintainable earnings of a business, with the difference between the two metrics being ‘Depreciation’ and Amortisation’.
The matter of Munja Bakehouse Pty Ltd [2024] NSWSC 6 involved a shareholder oppression dispute regarding a wholesale bakery which manufactured and distributed gluten free bakery goods.
The Plaintiffs and the Defendants both sought, essentially, the same relief, namely that the other party purchase the shares in Munja and Smith Street [the property owner] as their first preference, and a winding up order as their second preference.
The Defendants relied on a detailed expert report of Mr G and the Plaintiffs relied upon a report of Mr S. Mr G valued the shares in Munja alternatively on an EBITDA and EBIT basis.
Baker J stated that:
“It emerged in Mr G’s cross-examination that his valuation on an EBIT basis was likely distorted by the fact that Munja had made use of accelerated depreciation opportunities made available during the COVID-19 period, which would not ordinarily be available, so that its earnings after depreciation in that period would not be indicative of the earnings that it could ordinarily achieve. …” [67 ]
Counsel for the Defendants argued two main points in support of the use of EBIT:
Counsel for the Plaintiffs argued if an EBIT approach were adopted, it would be necessary to correct the EBIT at least in the FY23 year and determine a normalised EBIT and then further to correct Mr G’s EBIT range, because of the effect of accelerated depreciation adopted by Munja in FY23.
In summarising his findings, Black J stated that:
“… that an EBITDA valuation has the advantage, in principle, that it removes factors which can be affected by business owners’ decisions as to depreciation methods, financing structures and tax, so as to demonstrate the underlying earnings of the business, excluding the effect of its capital structure, and to that extent provides a better measure of a company’s operating performance. That approach is consistent with [other] evidence that an EBITDA valuation is ordinarily used in commercial transactions involving the sale and purchase of a business. Here, I would prefer Mr G’s EBITDA valuation of those shares to his EBIT valuation because it avoids the distortion for depreciation that would otherwise arise.” [70]
If you need assistance with a business valuation in your dispute please reach out to our team of experts today.
In family provision claims, an estate inventory may not tell the full financial story.
Explore how funds tracing and forensic accounting can clarify complex deceased estates.
Business integrity investigations – including fraud, conflicts of interest, bribery and corruption, procurement manipulation and other forms of financial misconduct – have always turned on evidence. The challenge is that decisive evidence is now often buried in vast volumes of email, chat, documents, invoices, ledgers and third-party data.