• Skip to content
  • Skip to navigation

Grant Thornton Australia

Grant Thornton uses cookies to monitor the performance of this website and improve user experience.

If you are happy to accept cookies from this site, please check the box.

To find out more about cookies, what they are and how we use them, please see our privacy notice, which also provides information on how to delete cookies from your hard drive.

How to be COVIDSafe when visiting Grant Thornton offices. Find out how

Global site
  • Global site
Grant Thorton Logo

Grant Thornton Logo Grant Thornton Logo

Contact us
  • Insights
  • Services
  • Industries
  • Meet our people
  • Careers
  • News centre
  • Locations
  • About us
  • Audit
  • Tax
  • Risk
  • Forensics
  • Deals
  • Finance and funding
  • Insolvency
  • Restructuring and turnaround
  • Business services
  • Consulting

  • Market services
  • Asia
  • Indigenous advisory
Audit Home
  • Compliance audits & reviews
  • Audit quality
  • Financial reporting advisory
  • Audit advisory
Tax Home
  • Corporate tax & advisory
  • Private business tax & advisory
  • Tax compliance
  • Employment tax
  • International tax
  • GST, stamp duty & indirect tax
  • Tax law
  • Research and development & government incentives
  • Data transformation and analytics
  • Corporate simplification
Risk Home
  • Payroll assurance
  • Cyber resilience
  • Internal audit
  • Financial crime
  • Consumer Data Right
  • Risk management
  • Controls assurance
  • Governance
  • Regulatory compliance
Forensics Home
  • Forensic accounting and dispute advisory
  • Investigations
  • Digital forensics
  • eDiscovery
Deals Home
  • Mergers and acquisitions
  • Acquisition search & strategy
  • Divestments
  • Operation deal services
  • Transaction advisory
  • Business valuations
  • Tax in mergers & acquisition
Finance and funding Home
  • Corporate finance
  • Debt advisory
  • Working capital optimisation
  • Capital markets
  • Capital raising
  • Private equity
  • Financial modelling
  • Payments advisory
Insolvency Home
  • Voluntary administration & DOCA
  • Corporate insolvency & liquidation
  • Complex and international insolvency
  • Safe Harbour advisory
  • Bankruptcy and personal insolvency
  • Creditor advisory services
  • Small business restructuring process
Restructuring and turnaround Home
  • Independent business reviews
  • Commercial performance
  • Safe Harbour advisory
  • Corporate simplification
  • Director advisory services
  • Debt advisory
Business services Home
  • Business planning & strategy
  • Private business company secretarial services
  • Outsourced accounting services
  • Superannuation and SMSF
  • Management reporting
  • Financial reporting
  • Forecasting & budgeting
  • ATO audit support
  • Family business consulting
  • Private business taxation and structuring
  • Outsourced CFO services
Consulting Home
  • Management consulting
  • Technology consulting
  • Financial consulting
Asia Home
  • China
  • India
  • Japan
  • Case study: Restructuring solutions
  • Agribusiness, food & beverage
  • Automotive dealers
  • Education
  • Energy & resources
  • Financial services
  • Health & aged care
  • Life sciences
  • Manufacturing
  • Not for Profit
  • Professional services
  • Public sector
  • Real estate & construction
  • Retail & consumer products
  • Technology & media
Agribusiness, food & beverage Home
Bite Size Dealtracker Food, Beverage & Agribusiness industry insights
Key insights for the Australian Food, Beverage & Agribusiness industry.
Financial services Home
  • Banking
  • Fintech
  • Private Health Insurance
  • Superannuation
  • Asset management
  • BEAR FAQs
  • Open banking
Royal Commission wrap up Top 10 things for Financial Services providers
Eleven months on from the first round of hearings for the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, Commissioner Hayne’s final report has been released.
Health & aged care Home
Aged Care Royal Commission Perspectives on the Future of Ageing
Transitions in ageing are not consistent and systematic as they are described by our ageing systems. Sometimes they are incremental, sometimes accidental, sometimes monumental, and they are always personal. We can create something better.
Life sciences Home
Biotechnology Industry Position survey Australia's biotechnology industry drives economic growth
The 2019 Biotechnology Industry Position survey conducted by Ausbiotech and supported by Grant Thornton has revealed that new technologies across regenerative medicine and medicinal cannabis are disrupting the industry, and Australia's global strength in clinical trials continues to drive contributions to the economic and social fabric of the country.
Manufacturing Home
mid-sized business report Manufacturing is critical to our economy – how can we support the sector?
Although the knock-on effects of the Australian automotive industry exiting our country are yet to be fully understood, the industry is evolving, and manufacturing continues to be a major employer and critical to our overall economy.
Not for Profit Home
NATIONAL OUTCOMES MEASUREMENT PROGRAM A practical framework
Royal Commissions and federal budgets are critical things for Nonprofit human service providers to be thinking about at this point in time.
Real estate & construction Home
mid-sized business report Supporting affordable housing requires planning, certainty – and tax reform
There is a lot of noise around the property sector at the moment – and it’s not all positive. Prices are down – but this shouldn’t be a surprise when some markets (namely Sydney & Melbourne) saw unprecedented hikes in recent years.
Retail & consumer products Home
GNC Group Consulting The Technology Trap: Online innovation in retail
I recently attended the NRF Retail Big Show in New York, an overwhelming smorgasbord of retail technology and new store concepts.
Technology & media Home
  • Telecommunications
Scaling-up for Growth From start-up to scale-up
Navigating the complexities of growth and maintaining previous success is a challenge for all mid-size businesses.
  • Working at Grant Thornton
  • Student opportunities
  • Experienced careers
  • Contact us
Working at Grant Thornton Home
  • Flexibility
  • Your career and development
  • Diversity and inclusion
  • In the community
  • What we offer you
Student opportunities Home
  • Graduates
  • Vacationer Program
  • The application process
  • FAQs
  • Student application tips and tricks
  • Positions available
Experienced careers Home
  • Client spotlight
  • Positions available
  1. Grant Thornton Australia | Audit, Tax and Advisory
  2. Client alerts
  3. 2014
  4. Tax Alert: GST update – Commissioner of Taxation v MBI Properties Pty Ltd

Tax Alert: GST update

05 Dec 2014
  • Tax Alert: GST update – Commissioner of Taxation v MBI Properties Pty Ltd

Commissioner of Taxation v MBI Properties Pty Ltd

On 3 December 2014, the High Court of Australia handed down its decision in Commissioner of Taxation v MBI Properties Pty Ltd (“MBI Properties”). 

The High Court held that a purchaser who acquires a reversionary interest in commercial residential premises subject to a lease will be making an input taxed supply where the purchaser expressly agrees to perform its obligations under the lease.  The decision confirms that the purchaser will be liable to an increasing adjustment under Division 135 of the GST Act. 

Background 
Facts
The facts in MBI Properties can be summarised as follows:

  1. South Steyne Hotel Pty Ltd (“South Steyne”) owned the Sebel Manly Beach Hotel.  The hotel was subdivided into individual apartments and a management lot.
  2. South Steyne entered into a lease agreement with Mirvac Management Ltd (“Mirvac”) in respect of each apartment.  Under each apartment lease, Mirvac (as operator) was required to use the apartment as part of a serviced apartment business. 
  3. South Steyne subsequently sold three apartments to MBI Properties Pty Ltd (“MBI”).  The apartments were sold subject to the existing lease between South Steyne and Mirvac.  
  4. For GST purposes, each sale was treated as a GST-free supply of a going concern. 

The Road to the High Court
The litigious history involved two related decisions: the 2009 Full Federal Court decision of South Steyne Hotel Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (“South Steyne”) and the Full Federal Court decision of MBI Properties Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation. 

In South Steyne, the Court held that the continuation of each apartment lease after the sale of the corresponding apartment by South Steyne to MBI did not result in a supply by MBI to Mirvac.   

In the Full Federal Court decision of MBI Properties, the Court confirmed that the acquirer of the reversionary interest does not make a supply to the lessee.

Basis of the appeal and response
In his appeal from the earlier decision of the Full Federal Court, the Commissioner challenged the conclusion of the Full Federal Court in South Steyne. 

The Commissioner argued that the continuation of each apartment lease resulted in an input taxed supply of residential premises by way of lease by MBI to Mirvac. This argument was based upon the premise that under the contracts of sale between South Steyne and MBI, MBI agreed to respect Mirvac’s right to use and occupy the apartments – this, the Commissioner argued, was an input taxed supply.         
In response, MBI argued that mere passive observance of an existing obligation was insufficient to give rise to a supply. In the alternative, MBI argued that if there was a supply it was not a supply that was made through an enterprise.

Issues
The primary issue in the appeal was whether the purchaser of the reversionary estate in land leased to a sitting tenant makes a supply for GST purposes to the tenant during the currency of the lease after completion of the purchase.

The decision
The High Court held that in electing to observe the ongoing obligation between South Steyne and Mirvac, MBI made an input taxed supply of residential premises by way of lease to Mirvac throughout the remaining term of the lease. Relevantly, the High Court held that this supply was made through the same enterprise that MBI has previously acquired the premises from South Steyne.     

Impact
The decision in MBI Properties confirms that a purchaser of a reversionary interest in land where the land is subject to a lease (being input taxed) will be liable to an increasing adjustment under Division 135 of the GST Act where the acquisition consisted of a GST-free supply of a going concern. On this basis, the decision has effectively barred any potential refunds or structuring opportunities for taxpayers that arose from the previous decision of the Full Federal Court – in effect, the status quo of the position prior to MBI Properties has been restored. 

The decision will also impact commercial leases and confirms that the purchaser of a reversionary interest in land where the land is subject to a commercial lease (being taxable) will continue to be liable for GST on the ongoing leasing supply.

As an observation, the decision confirms the extremely broad definition of “supply” in the GST Act. The High Court confirmed that the observance of a contractual obligation to refrain from taking some action or to tolerate a situation will amount to a “supply” for GST purposes and that a “positive act” is not always necessary. This appears to be at odds with the Commissioner’s views in GSTR Ruling, GSTR 2006/9 that to make a supply, an entity must do something. It will be interesting to see whether the Commissioner amends GSTR 2006/9 to take into account the High Court’s view.

For more information please contact:

Tony Windle
Tony Windle
Partner & National Head of Indirect Tax Brisbane
Email address https://au.linkedin.com/in/tonywindlegt Tony Windle VCard
View full profile
Share this page
  • Share this page on Facebook LinkedIn
  • Share this page on Twitter Twitter
  • Share this page on LinkedIn LinkedIn
  • Share this page on Wechat WeChat
  • Share this page via email Email
  • Grant Thornton on Youtube
  • LinkedIn icon
  • Twitter icon
  • Facebook icon
Connectclose
  • Contact us
  • Locations
  • Meet our people
  • Subscribe
  • Staff portal
Aboutclose
  • About us
  • Careers
  • News centre
  • Client alerts
  • Grant Thornton Foundation
  • Grant Thornton Affinity
Legalclose
  • Privacy
  • Compliance and ethics
  • Disclaimer
  • Site map

© 2021 Grant Thornton Australia Limited – All rights reserved

    • EN
    • Contact us