• Skip to content
  • Skip to navigation

Grant Thornton Australia

Grant Thornton uses cookies to monitor the performance of this website and improve user experience.

If you are happy to accept cookies from this site, please check the box.

To find out more about cookies, what they are and how we use them, please see our privacy notice, which also provides information on how to delete cookies from your hard drive.

How to be COVIDSafe when visiting Grant Thornton offices. Find out how

Global site
  • Global site
Grant Thorton Logo

Grant Thornton Logo Grant Thornton Logo

Contact us
  • Insights
  • Services
  • Industries
  • Meet our people
  • Careers
  • News centre
  • Locations
  • About us
  • Audit
  • Tax
  • Risk
  • Forensics
  • Deals
  • Finance and funding
  • Insolvency
  • Restructuring and turnaround
  • Business services
  • Consulting

  • Market services
  • Asia
  • Indigenous advisory
Audit Home
  • Compliance audits & reviews
  • Audit quality
  • Financial reporting advisory
  • Audit advisory
Tax Home
  • Corporate tax & advisory
  • Private business tax & advisory
  • Tax compliance
  • Employment tax
  • International tax
  • GST, stamp duty & indirect tax
  • Tax law
  • Research and development & government incentives
  • Data transformation and analytics
  • Corporate simplification
Risk Home
  • Payroll assurance
  • Cyber resilience
  • Internal audit
  • Financial crime
  • Consumer Data Right
  • Risk management
  • Controls assurance
  • Governance
  • Regulatory compliance
Forensics Home
  • Forensic accounting and dispute advisory
  • Investigations
  • Digital forensics
  • eDiscovery
Deals Home
  • Mergers and acquisitions
  • Acquisition search & strategy
  • Divestments
  • Operation deal services
  • Transaction advisory
  • Business valuations
  • Tax in mergers & acquisition
Finance and funding Home
  • Corporate finance
  • Debt advisory
  • Working capital optimisation
  • Capital markets
  • Capital raising
  • Private equity
  • Financial modelling
  • Payments advisory
Insolvency Home
  • Voluntary administration & DOCA
  • Corporate insolvency & liquidation
  • Complex and international insolvency
  • Safe Harbour advisory
  • Bankruptcy and personal insolvency
  • Creditor advisory services
  • Small business restructuring process
Restructuring and turnaround Home
  • Independent business reviews
  • Commercial performance
  • Safe Harbour advisory
  • Corporate simplification
  • Director advisory services
  • Debt advisory
Business services Home
  • Business planning & strategy
  • Private business company secretarial services
  • Outsourced accounting services
  • Superannuation and SMSF
  • Management reporting
  • Financial reporting
  • Forecasting & budgeting
  • ATO audit support
  • Family business consulting
  • Private business taxation and structuring
  • Outsourced CFO services
Consulting Home
  • Management consulting
  • Technology consulting
  • Financial consulting
Asia Home
  • China
  • India
  • Japan
  • Case study: Restructuring solutions
  • Agribusiness, food & beverage
  • Automotive dealers
  • Education
  • Energy & resources
  • Financial services
  • Health & aged care
  • Life sciences
  • Manufacturing
  • Not for Profit
  • Professional services
  • Public sector
  • Real estate & construction
  • Retail & consumer products
  • Technology & media
Agribusiness, food & beverage Home
Bite Size Dealtracker Food, Beverage & Agribusiness industry insights
Key insights for the Australian Food, Beverage & Agribusiness industry.
Financial services Home
  • Banking
  • Fintech
  • Private Health Insurance
  • Superannuation
  • Asset management
  • BEAR FAQs
  • Open banking
Royal Commission wrap up Top 10 things for Financial Services providers
Eleven months on from the first round of hearings for the Royal Commission into Misconduct in the Banking, Superannuation and Financial Services Industry, Commissioner Hayne’s final report has been released.
Health & aged care Home
Aged Care Royal Commission Perspectives on the Future of Ageing
Transitions in ageing are not consistent and systematic as they are described by our ageing systems. Sometimes they are incremental, sometimes accidental, sometimes monumental, and they are always personal. We can create something better.
Life sciences Home
Biotechnology Industry Position survey Australia's biotechnology industry drives economic growth
The 2019 Biotechnology Industry Position survey conducted by Ausbiotech and supported by Grant Thornton has revealed that new technologies across regenerative medicine and medicinal cannabis are disrupting the industry, and Australia's global strength in clinical trials continues to drive contributions to the economic and social fabric of the country.
Manufacturing Home
mid-sized business report Manufacturing is critical to our economy – how can we support the sector?
Although the knock-on effects of the Australian automotive industry exiting our country are yet to be fully understood, the industry is evolving, and manufacturing continues to be a major employer and critical to our overall economy.
Not for Profit Home
NATIONAL OUTCOMES MEASUREMENT PROGRAM A practical framework
Royal Commissions and federal budgets are critical things for Nonprofit human service providers to be thinking about at this point in time.
Real estate & construction Home
mid-sized business report Supporting affordable housing requires planning, certainty – and tax reform
There is a lot of noise around the property sector at the moment – and it’s not all positive. Prices are down – but this shouldn’t be a surprise when some markets (namely Sydney & Melbourne) saw unprecedented hikes in recent years.
Retail & consumer products Home
GNC Group Consulting The Technology Trap: Online innovation in retail
I recently attended the NRF Retail Big Show in New York, an overwhelming smorgasbord of retail technology and new store concepts.
Technology & media Home
  • Telecommunications
Scaling-up for Growth From start-up to scale-up
Navigating the complexities of growth and maintaining previous success is a challenge for all mid-size businesses.
  • Working at Grant Thornton
  • Student opportunities
  • Experienced careers
  • Contact us
Working at Grant Thornton Home
  • Flexibility
  • Your career and development
  • Diversity and inclusion
  • In the community
  • What we offer you
Student opportunities Home
  • Graduates
  • Vacationer Program
  • The application process
  • FAQs
  • Student application tips and tricks
  • Positions available
Experienced careers Home
  • Client spotlight
  • Positions available
  1. Grant Thornton Australia | Audit, Tax and Advisory
  2. Client alerts
  3. 2014
  4. ATO Issues - New risk assessment for Professional Practice

ATO Issues - New risk assessment for Professional Practice

07 Jul 2014
  • ATO Issues - New risk assessment for Professional Practice

The Australian Tax Office (ATO) has expressed concern about the way in which professional practitioners are structuring how Principle Practitioners are remunerated.

To address these concerns the ATO today released additional guidelines to professional practices which they will use to determine the practices likelihood for audit selection.

The information below outlines why the ATO is concerned, what the changes are and what action you should take now in light of these guidelines.

ATO concerns:

  • Individual Practitioners not being adequately remunerated directly for services rendered;
  • Transfer of assets, particularly goodwill, into new structures without addressing capital gains tax issues; and 
  • Were there tax avoidance reasons for restructure?

Who does it apply to?
Anyone carrying on professional practice.  Whilst the release provides examples related to legal and accounting practices, it is not limited to those professionals and applies to all professional practices including medical, architectural and engineering practices.

What the ATO said
A new risk assessment tool will apply for audit selection for tax returns starting with the 2015 tax year. There is a higher risk of a Tax Audit if you can’t satisfy at least one of the following three tests:

Test 1
- The individual receives comparable remuneration in their own hands as an appropriate return for the services they provide to the firm. “Appropriate” is measured as the level of remuneration paid to the highest band of professional employees providing equivalent services to the firm, or if there is no such employee in the firm, industry benchmarks for the relevant region; and/or

Test 2
- 50% or greater of the total profit distributions the partner receives in the relevant income year are distributed directly to the individual practitioner (including from associated service entities); and/or

Test 3
- The individual practitioner and their associated entities have an effective tax rate of 30% or higher on the profits derived from the firm, an amount is distributed to the practitioner and there are no other higher risk features to the arrangement (these would include such things as income injection to access carried forward losses, inappropriate access to business profits, avoidance of Division 7A or other tax benefits or non-tax advantages which are dependent on taxable income).

ATO approach
As with Service Trusts, the ATO’s position is not that the current law overwhelmingly supports its position, but simply that you either comply with ATO guideline or be prepared to take your case to court. Are you prepared to fund the cost and time to challenge the ATO’s view to establish the correct legal position? Unfortunately, the answer for most is no.

The ATO’s desire to maintain the linkage between ownership and reward for services rendered is becoming redundant and simply overtaken by professional standards legislating changes covering the professional and commercial imperatives such as increased competition, technology changes and globalisation in professional practices.  Professional practices are fourth on the list of sectors facing change from what is termed digital disruption.

The ATO’s big stick – Part  IVA General Tax anti-avoidance measures

The 2013 amendments to Part  IVA are very broad and have the potential to undo the simplest of any tax planning. There is considerable debate as to when these provisions should be used. Are they designed solely for use in large dollar transactions or at an individual level where, although the business operation is commercial, the effect triggers a tax benefit?

In this publication, the ATO indicates that Part IVA will be a consideration.

The critical issue is to consider, what is the amount the law requires a person to be compensated for from the provision of their labour?

This question has not been answered post the 2013 amendments.

What should you do?

If restructuring, identify the commercial benefits sought in undertaking the restructure:

  • New enterprise 
  • Limited liability and asset protection 
  • Litigation
  • Succession
  • Commercial reality 
  • Bank funding

Review profit sharing arrangements in light of the three ATO tests

  • Do I satisfy one of the tests?
  • Consider the impact on the practice and equity participants
  • Can and will you comply?

Have you restructured?

  • Did you address CGT and GST issues?
  • Did you address stamp duty?
  • Is the restructure documented?
  • What was the commercial benefit?
  • What governance steps have been implemented to reflect the structure used.

How much income does an individual professional practitioner need to earn?

  • Is the income ‘business income’ or ‘personal services income’?
  • ATO risk profile considerations
  • Service trust guidelines
  • Commercial considerations relevant to circumstances

Do I need professional help?
If any of these questions are of concern please contact one of our team members or a Partner in Grant Thornton who will put you in contact with the right person to help you.  Alternatively send an email to dist.nat.professionalservices@au.gt.com which we will respond to.

Grant Thornton’s Professional Practice Group
Our Professional Practice Group is concerned by the ATO’s approach and is either by direct participation or lobbying through professional associations, seeking greater clarity expressed in relation to the tax treatment of professional practices.

Current issues include goodwill, service trust profits, practitioner remuneration and business income verses personal income.

We would be pleased to hear your view on these issues. Contact us via dist.nat.professionalservices@au.gt.com or call one of our team members to discuss your concerns.

Share this page
  • Share this page on Facebook LinkedIn
  • Share this page on Twitter Twitter
  • Share this page on LinkedIn LinkedIn
  • Share this page on Wechat WeChat
  • Share this page via email Email
  • Grant Thornton on Youtube
  • LinkedIn icon
  • Twitter icon
  • Facebook icon
Connectclose
  • Contact us
  • Locations
  • Meet our people
  • Subscribe
  • Staff portal
Aboutclose
  • About us
  • Careers
  • News centre
  • Client alerts
  • Grant Thornton Foundation
  • Grant Thornton Affinity
Legalclose
  • Privacy
  • Compliance and ethics
  • Disclaimer
  • Site map

© 2021 Grant Thornton Australia Limited – All rights reserved

    • EN
    • Contact us